Arrests

Image for Wiseman, Shala Jade  - 18 3922.1 FINANCIAL EXPLOITATION OF AN OLDER ADULT OR CARE DEPENDENT PERSON and 3 additional charges
Arrest
Jan 8, 2026
On 01/05/2026 Newville Police filed criminal charges on Shala Wiseman (19 y/o) of Carlisle. It was reported by a Power of Attorney that someone was stealing from his mother (83 y/o). Newville Police reviewed banking records and executed a Search Warrant to PayPal. The fin...
read more
Image for Smith, Benjamin   - 75 3733 A- FLEEING OR ATTEMPTING TO ELUDE POLICE (FELONY) and 3 additional charges
Arrest
Jun 13, 2025
On 04/08/2025 at approximately 1852 Newville Police observed a brown Nissan sedan on East Big Spring Ave with an expired vehicle inspection. As the Officer did a U-turn to get behind the Nissan, the Nissan accelerated across South High St onto West Big Spring Ave. The Officer ...
read more
Image for Hill, Rodney Allan  - 18 2709 A4 (M3) Harassment - Comm. Lewd Threatening etc. Language
Arrest
Apr 17, 2025
On 04/17/2025 at approximately 1130 Rodney Hill was escorted by Newville Borough Police to MDJ Hanner's Court room in Newville for a Preliminary Hearing. At the conclusion of the hearing, bail conditions remained in place which prevent Hill from having any contact with his vic...
read more
Image for Hill, Rodney Allan  - Title 18 3503B1I Defiant Trespass Actual Communication to Actor
Arrest
Apr 10, 2025
On 4/7/2025 at approx. 16:49hrs the Newville Borough Police were called to a residence on Pennsylvania Ave. for a domestic. There was no suspect on location upon arrival. The female victim advised she is being harassed by ex-boyfriend Rodney Hill (60) of Carlisle, PA. The vict...
read more
Image for Muscatell, Dominic H  - Title 18 3929 (a)(1) Retail theft
Arrest
Jan 22, 2025
On 12/18/2024 the Family Dollar reported a retail theft that occurred on the previous day. It was reported that on 12/17/2024 at approximately 17:30hrs a young white male entered the store carrying a backpack. The store provided video which depicted the individual placing mult...
read more
Image for Muscatell, Dominic H  - (1) count 18 3921(b) Theft by Unlawful Taking (F2) and 3 additional charges
Arrest
Created Jan 17, 2025 / Updated Jan 19, 2025
On 12-19-2024 Newville Police began to receive reports of vehicles being broke into, missing debit cards, unlawful use of debit cards, and missing personal belongings such as tools, medical equipment, social security cards and a handgun. Newville Police launched an investigati...
read more
Image for Williams, Trivon D  - 1 Count Scattering Rubbish (S)
Arrest
Jul 24, 2024
On 7/20/2024 Newville Police discovered a mattress that was discarded at the Community Aid Bin on West Street. Through investigation it was determined an out of state truck driver stopped in the parking lot and discarded the mattress on 7/18/2024. Subsequently, Trivon D. ...
read more
Image for Boyd, Lucas Daniel  - 1 count of Title 35: 780-113 (a32) - Possession of Drug Paraphernalia (M) and 1 additional charge
Arrest
Jun 25, 2024
On 5/20/2024 at approx. 10:00hrs Newville Police received a report of a suspicious vehicle parked at the fuel pumps at 2 Rich Street Newville, PA. Upon arrival to the area a red Ford Fusion was observed parked directly in front of the gas pumps. Lucas Boyd (26) of Newville, PA...
read more
Image for Spece, Michele J  - (1 count ) Retail Theft F3 & (1 count) Receiving Stolen Property (M3)
Arrest
May 16, 2024
On 5/13/2023 Newville Police received a report of a non-active Retail Theft that occurred at Saylors Market on  5/7/2024. After review of in-store video it was determined Michele Spece entered the store on 5/7/2024 and placed multiple items inside a bag she carried in wit...
read more
Image for Payne, Cassandra   - 35 780-113a32 Possession of Drug Paraphernalia and 2 additional charges
Arrest
Mar 18, 2024
On 03/14/2024 at approximately 15:06hrs Newville Police conducted a traffic stop on a Honda Civic with inoperable brake lights in the area of Line St and Liberty Ave. The operator was identified as Cassandra Payne (29) of Newville. It was discovered that Payne was in possessio...
read more