Skip to main content
Pequea Township Police Department logo

Pequea Township Police Department

Chief John Michener
Submit a Tip
Arrest

Stoltzfus, Gary Eugene

  • 1ROBBERY
  • 1SIMPLE ASSAULT
  • 1HARSSMENT
Age
69
Race
White
Gender
Male
Arrested
Jan 24, 2026

Presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

On 1/24/26, a domestic disturbance occurred in the parking lot of a business in the 400 block of Long Lane in Pequea Township. As a result, Gary E. Stoltzfus, 68, of New Providence, has been charged with several criminal offenses.

Stoltzfus allegedly assaulted a 24-year-old female from York, PA. The assault involved biting the victim on the arm and throwing her to the ground while stealing her cell phone. Witnesses intervened, separating the two individuals and calling 911. The victim suffered minor injuries.

Stoltzfus has been charged with one count each of Robbery, Simple Assault, and Harassment. He was taken into custody without incident and arraigned before MDJ Richardson. Stoltzfus was committed to Lancaster County Prison after failing to post $5,000 bail.

All persons are considered innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

Show map
Share

Pequea Township Police DepartmentCRIMEWATCH · Lancaster County

Get alerts in your inbox

Press releases, crime alerts and news. Always free.

Get the app: App Store · Google Play