Skip to main content
Montour Township Police Department logo

Montour Township Police Department

Philip Savidge, Chief of Police
Submit a Tip
Arrest

Usefara, Matthew

  • 1RECKLESSLY ENDANGERING ANOTHER PERSON
  • 1SIMPLE ASSAULT
  • 1RECKLESS DRIVING
  • 1CARELESS DRIVING
  • 1NO-PASSING ZONES
  • 1DRIVING ON ROADWAYS LANED FOR TRAFFIC
Age
35
Race
White
Gender
Male
Arrested
Nov 2, 2026

Presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

On Saturday, October 31, 2026, at approximately 1235 hours, a road rage incident involving a gun occurred at the intersection of Red Mill Road and Hunt Club Road, which began in Montour Township. Officer Tonkinson responded to the scene. 

Michael MIRABILE was traveling north on Montour Blvd (SR11) when he encountered a silver Nissan Pathfinder, driven by Matthew USEFARA, on the on-ramp to Mall Blvd. (SR42).

The incident escalated when MIRABILE attempted to pass USEFARA, who slammed on his brakes. MIRABILE then crossed over the cement divider, traveling northbound in the southbound lane, and eventually turned onto Red Mill Road. USEFARA followed MIRABILE, passing him and slamming on his brakes, causing MIRABILE to strike the back of USEFARA's vehicle.

USEFARA exited his vehicle to confront MIRABILE, who pointed a gun at him, telling him to call the police. MIRABILE claimed he was trying to leave the scene and had asked his friend to call the police.

Both parties provided written statements, and dash camera footage was obtained. After reviewing the evidence, it was determined that MIRABILE was traveling at a high rate of speed and crossed over the cement divider, traveling into oncoming traffic. USEFARA followed MIRABILE, and the incident culminated in MIRABILE pointing a gun at USEFARA. 

At the conclusion of the investigation, Officer Tonkinson filed charges against both involved. 

Show map
Share

Montour Township Police DepartmentCRIMEWATCH · Montour County

Get alerts in your inbox

Press releases, crime alerts and news. Always free.

Get the app: App Store · Google Play