On 03/21/2025, at approximately 2218 hours, Shafer was involved in a traffic stop investigation on Trolley Road and subsequently arrested for suspicion of DUI.

After receiving the toxicology report, Jared Andrew Shafer was charged with 5 counts of DUI, 1 count of Possession of Marijuana (M), 1 count of Possession of Drug Paraphernalia (M), 1 count of Driving While License Privilege is Suspended (M3), and 2 Traffic Violations on 08/22/2025.