On 7/16/2026, the Shippensburg Police Department took a phone call from Amber Scott reporting a possible incident that occurred at Aroogas. Upon conducting an investigation, it was found that Scott identified herself as a private investigator to Aroogas staff. Later, an interview with Scott was conducted, and it was found that she did not have the proper credentials or a license to be considered a private investigator or to have the ability to conduct such investigations. 

Court was held on 9/9/2026, at which time Scott pleaded guilty.