On 05/24/2026 at approximately 6:48 PM, the Carlisle Police Department was dispatched for the report of an active robbery with a firearm at the Carroll Mart, located at 330 N Hanover St in the Borough of Carlisle.  The resulting investigation determined two individual victims were robbed, and that two suspects had fled and entered a residence in the 200 block of N Bedford St.  At approximately 10:00 PM, with the assistance of the Cumberland County Special Response Team, a search warrant was executed on the residence. Christopher Sheibley was identified as a suspect in the case and subsequently arrested for robbery, theft, possession with intent to deliver a controlled substance, and several other charges.