Youngwood, PA -- Westmoreland County Detectives filed additional theft charges against a Youngwood gun shop owner who is accused of pocketing more than $153,000 of customers' money. 

Tracey McMahan, 67, is accused of taking approximately $3,600 from four customers who made down payments toward the purchase of firearms from her business, Hi-Grade Shooters Supply. 

McMahan was charged by Westmoreland County Detectives and state police in several other theft cases in 2023 and 2024. 

County Detectives were contacted by a victim in West Virginia after paying McMahan $1,800 for the purchase of two shotguns in June of 2023. The victim never received the shotguns and communication was severed. 

In May 2024, a victim and business owner in New Mexico contacted the Westmoreland County Detective Bureau regarding a possible theft involving McMahan. 

The victim provided a payment of $1,800 to McMahan for the purchase of a rifle with a scope but failed to receive the item.

In June of 2024, a victim from Amity, PA reported to detectives that they provided McMahan a shotgun to sell at her business on consignment in the amount of $3,200 but never received the funds from the sale and could not make contact with McMahan.

A North Huntingdon man reported to detectives that in August of 2024 he provided McMahan with a shotgun to sell on consignment in the amount of $13,000. McMahan relayed to the victim that the shotgun was sold, however McMahan is accused of retaining the funds from the sale. 

McMahan is facing several additional theft-related counts and receiving stolen property.  

Disclaimer: To the extent that pending criminal matters are discussed, all such charges are merely accusations and all defendants are presumed innocent until and unless proven guilty.