Search Link search
Home
About Us
  • Divisions
    • Legal Division
    • Investigative Division
    • Victim and Witness Services
  • Calendar
  • What Do We Do?
Crime
  • Child Abuse Crimes
  • Elder and Care Dependent Abuse
  • Animal Abuse
  • Human Trafficking
    • 2nd Quarter, 2024 Newsletter
Programs
  • ARD/DUI
  • Bad Check Program
  • Bingo Licensing
  • Small Games of Chance Licensing
  • Pathways to Recovery
Resources
  • External Links
  • Victim/Witness Handbook
  • Drug Forfeiture Accounts
  • Photo Release Policy
  • Pro Se Online Application for Review
  • Victim Right of Access Form
  • Your Rights
Lancaster's Law Enforcement Series
  • District Attorney Adams Announces Lancaster Law Enforcement Series
  • Columbia Borough Police Officer Nate Miller
  • East Cocalico Township Police Officer Keith McCabe
  • East Cocalico Township Police Officer Rachael Odenwalt
  • East Hempfield Township Police Sergeant Anthony Lombardo
  • East Hempfield Township Police Sergeant Richard Gauck
  • East Lampeter Township Police Detective Sergeant Preston Gentzler
  • East Lampeter Township Police Officer Samuel Sanger
  • Elizabethtown Police Officer Anthony Lederer
  • Ephrata Police Officer Robert Wolpert
  • Lancaster City Bureau of Police Officer Harry Valverde
  • Lancaster County Sheriff's Office Corporal David Cole
  • Manheim Borough Police Sergeant Jason Riggle
  • Manheim Township Police Officer Alyse Gallagher
  • Manheim Township Police Officer Marc Wiczkowski
  • Manor Township Police Officer Steven Haas
  • Millersville University Police Lieutenant Arthur White
  • Northern Lancaster County Regional Police Department Detective Theresa Stauffer
  • Northern Lancaster County Regional Police Officer Brandon Legerlotz
  • Pequea Township Police Officer Victoria Walton
  • Quarryville Borough Police Officer Mitchell Melot
  • West Earl Township Police Department Officer Jake Waltz
  • West Earl Township Police Officer Samantha Heise
  • West Hempfield Township Police Officer Cameron Powers
  • West Lampeter Township Police Officer Ed McLaughlin
  • West Lampeter Township Police Officer Juan Guadalupe
RTK RequestOur CountyContact Us
FOLLOW
SUBMIT A TIP
  • Login Link LOGIN
  • Map Link CRIME MAP
Lancaster County DA
  • 50 North Duke Street, 6th Floor, Lancaster, PA 17608
  • (717) 299-8100
  • Lancaster County District Attorney's Office on Facebook
  • Lancaster County District Attorney's Office on X
Heather Adams, District Attorney
lancasterda.org
CRIMEWATCH / US / PA / Lancaster County
  • Login Link LOGIN
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • SUBMIT A TIP
Lancaster County District Attorney's Office Homepage
Lancaster County District Attorney's Office Logo

Lancaster County District Attorney's Office

Heather Adams, District Attorney
lancasterda.org
Search Link search Map Link CRIME MAP
  • 50 North Duke Street, 6th Floor, Lancaster, PA 17608
  • (717) 299-8100
  • Lancaster County District Attorney's Office on Facebook
  • Lancaster County District Attorney's Office on X
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Divisions
      • Legal Division
      • Investigative Division
      • Victim and Witness Services
    • Calendar
    • What Do We Do?
  • Crime
    • Child Abuse Crimes
    • Elder and Care Dependent Abuse
    • Animal Abuse
    • Human Trafficking
      • 2nd Quarter, 2024 Newsletter
  • Programs
    • ARD/DUI
    • Bad Check Program
    • Bingo Licensing
    • Small Games of Chance Licensing
    • Pathways to Recovery
  • Resources
    • External Links
    • Victim/Witness Handbook
    • Drug Forfeiture Accounts
    • Photo Release Policy
    • Pro Se Online Application for Review
    • Victim Right of Access Form
    • Your Rights
  • Lancaster's Law Enforcement Series
    • District Attorney Adams Announces Lancaster Law Enforcement Series
    • Columbia Borough Police Officer Nate Miller
    • East Cocalico Township Police Officer Keith McCabe
    • East Cocalico Township Police Officer Rachael Odenwalt
    • East Hempfield Township Police Sergeant Anthony Lombardo
    • East Hempfield Township Police Sergeant Richard Gauck
    • East Lampeter Township Police Detective Sergeant Preston Gentzler
    • East Lampeter Township Police Officer Samuel Sanger
    • Elizabethtown Police Officer Anthony Lederer
    • Ephrata Police Officer Robert Wolpert
    • Lancaster City Bureau of Police Officer Harry Valverde
    • Lancaster County Sheriff's Office Corporal David Cole
    • Manheim Borough Police Sergeant Jason Riggle
    • Manheim Township Police Officer Alyse Gallagher
    • Manheim Township Police Officer Marc Wiczkowski
    • Manor Township Police Officer Steven Haas
    • Millersville University Police Lieutenant Arthur White
    • Northern Lancaster County Regional Police Department Detective Theresa Stauffer
    • Northern Lancaster County Regional Police Officer Brandon Legerlotz
    • Pequea Township Police Officer Victoria Walton
    • Quarryville Borough Police Officer Mitchell Melot
    • West Earl Township Police Department Officer Jake Waltz
    • West Earl Township Police Officer Samantha Heise
    • West Hempfield Township Police Officer Cameron Powers
    • West Lampeter Township Police Officer Ed McLaughlin
    • West Lampeter Township Police Officer Juan Guadalupe
  • RTK Request
  • Our County
  • Contact Us

Want to Subscribe?

To follow Lancaster County District Attorney's Office, click the button below.


Download the CRIMEWATCH app and follow Lancaster County District Attorney's Office.

App StoreGoogle Play

micah_stewart_2015.png
cortneyfry2.png
micah_stewart_2004.png

Federal Court Denies 'Intoxicated' Defense Argument of Lifer who Killed Cortney Fry in 2004

An inmate serving life for killing his girlfriend, days after she gave birth to their daughter, had his latest appeal for relief denied.

A federal district court in Philadelphia recently denied Micah Stewart’s argument that his initial appeal lawyer, and trial lawyer, were ineffective.

Stewart, now 30, has served about 10 years of his sentence for killing 19-year-old Cortney Fry in July 2004, bludgeoning her in the head with a screwdriver.

About six months later, a hunter found Fry’s body, burned, in a Manor Township field.

Stewart was convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to life without parole. He’s also serving a separate 30-to-60-year term for viciously beating a cellmate at Lancaster County Prison.

On appeal, Stewart alleged that his appeal lawyer should’ve raised a potential diminished capacity defense; specifically, that Stewart was high on crack cocaine and marijuana at the time of the killing.

Because of that, Stewart argued, he was incapable of forming a specific intent to kill – an element of first-degree murder.

The federal court, in its order, wrote there was no testimony at trial to support such a defense. Assistant District Attorney Amber Czerniakowski argued that in response to Stewart's appeal.

Stewart has exhausted all appeals at the state level.

Stewart, 19 when he was charged, was apparently enraged over a belief that Fry was having an affair and the baby wasn’t his. A paternity test proved the child was his.

Other powerful evidence in the conviction were confessions Stewart made to his stepmother and stepbrother about killing Fry.

Also, police found gloves stained with Fry’s blood, and a screwdriver – the murder weapon – in Stewart’s car.

A witness also saw Stewart discard Fry’s clothing and other belongings in a trash bin two days before she was reported missing.

MEDIA CONTACT: Brett A. Hambright, 717-295-2041; bhambright@co.lancaster.pa.us; Twitter: @BrettHambright

Created Jan 29, 2016 @ 4:40 PM | Updated Feb 1, 2016 @ 3:19 PM
micah_stewart_2015.png
cortneyfry2.png
micah_stewart_2004.png
Lancaster County DA
50 North Duke Street
6th Floor
Lancaster, PA 17608
EnglishEnglish
EnglishEnglishAmharicAmharicArabicArabicChinese (Simplified)Chinese (Simplified)Chinese (Traditional)Chinese (Traditional)DutchDutchFilipinoFilipinoFrenchFrenchGermanGermanHaitian CreoleHaitian CreoleHindiHindiItalianItalianJapaneseJapaneseKoreanKoreanPolishPolishPortuguesePortugueseRussianRussianSpanishSpanishSwahiliSwahiliVietnameseVietnamese
  • Contact Lancaster County DA
  • Compliance
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Accessibility
IMPORTANT NOTIFICATION. Individuals accused of crimes and depicted on this and affiliate sites are presumed innocent until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. Content on the CRIMEWATCH® platform and this website is posted, administered, and owned by law enforcement agencies, and is subject to change at any time. CRIMEWATCH Technologies, Inc., its owners, officers, directors, employees, agents, affiliates, and subsidiaries, provide NO WARRANTY OR REPRESENTATION regarding the contents of the CRIMEWATCH® platform or this website, and are not responsible for its accuracy, timeliness, or relevancy. For information about how to request the removal of inaccurate information, please go here.
CRIMEWATCH Technologies Homepage
CRIMEWATCH® and the Eye Design are registered trademarks of CRIMEWATCH Technologies, Inc. © 2026 CRIMEWATCH Technologies, Inc.

Lancaster County District Attorney's Office

CRIMEWATCH - Lancaster County

All content is free to read. Subscribe to get email alerts when new updates are posted.

Get notified about press releases, crime alerts, and news from the Lancaster County District Attorney's Office.


Also available on

App StoreGoogle Play