Family Feud Turns Frightening at Wawa as Gun Is Pulled

On September 16, 2026, at approximately 3:59 P.M., Warrington Police responded to Wawa for a report of two males fighting. The caller also reported that one of the males pulled out a handgun, racked the slide, and pointed it at the other male.

Officers reviewed Wawa’s surveillance video, which showed 34-year-old Joseph Michael Klusman II of Doylestown exiting a vehicle while holding a black firearm. Klusman II pointed the handgun directly at the other male’s face, manually cycled the slide twice, and again pointed the firearm at him. The investigation determined the two males were related. Two live rounds were also located on the ground. 

Other victims stated they took cover fearing for their life as Klusman II was pointing the firearm. 

Klusman II was located a short distance away. The firearm was later recovered from a backpack being carried by his girlfriend, 44-year-old Michelle Lee Milwrick, also of Doylestown.

Surveillance video also showed Milwrick selecting $27.70 worth of merchandise from Wawa before exiting the store without paying.

Both Klusman II and Milwrick were placed under arrest and transported to the Warrington Police Department, where they were processed.

Klusman II was arraigned by Judge Wertman, who set bail at $80,000 or 10% cash. Milwrick was arraigned by Judge O’Neill. Both were unable to post bail and were transported to the Bucks County Correctional Facility.

Criminal charges, and any discussion thereof, are merely allegations and all defendants are presumed innocent until and unless proven guilty.